Square Payroll Software Review

(April 2025)

Square-Payroll-Software-Review

Table of Contents

Our Verdict

Here’s the scoop. If you’re running a small to medium-sized business and you want a payroll solution that won’t have you pulling your hair out, Square Payroll could be a winner for you.

Square Payroll software offers a user-friendly and intuitive platform for managing payroll tasks. With its simple interface, it’s easy to set up and run payroll for your team. Seriously, you don’t need to be a tech wizard to get this thing up and running. From setting up direct deposits to generating those all-important pay stubs, the whole process is a breeze.

If you’re running a massive enterprise with complex payroll needs, Square Payroll might not have all the bells and whistles you’re after. It’s not the Swiss Army knife of payroll software, but it does what it does really well.

Pros

  • Has a user-friendly interface
  • Offers automated tax calculations to save time and reduce risk of tax-related errors
  • Provides a streamlined onboarding process

Cons

  • Has limited scalability
  • Has limited advanced HR features
  • Has limited customization
Who Square Payroll Software Is Best For

Square payroll software is best for businesses if you:

  • Are looking for an affordable payroll solution that still gets the job done effectively
  • Wants to minimize the stress of tax calculations and compliance
  • Are already using other square products for business operation
  • Own a startup or small business
Who Square Payroll Software Isn’t Right For

Consider an alternative if you:

  • Own a large enterprise
  • Own a business that needs advanced HR features
  • Own companies with multi-state payroll
  • Are in an industry with unique payroll structure
  • Own companies with international operations
What Square Payroll Software Offers
What-Square-Payroll-Software-Offers
  • Automated Payroll Processing
  • Tax Calculation and Filing
  • Employee Self-Service
  • Direct Deposits
  • Benefits Management
  • Time-Tracking Integration
  • Contractor Payments
  • Employee Onboarding
  • Payroll Reporting
  • Integration With Square Ecosystem
Square Payroll Software Details

Automated Payroll Processing

Gone are the days of manual calculations and time-consuming spreadsheet entries. The software takes care of calculating employee wages, taxes, and deductions accurately and efficiently. This not only saves valuable time but also minimizes the risk of errors, ensuring that employees are paid accurately and on time.

Tax Calculations and Filing

Tax compliance is a critical aspect of payroll management. Square Payroll’s tax calculation and filing features are a significant relief for your business. The software automatically calculates federal and state payroll taxes based on the latest tax rates and regulations. It takes care of tax filings and payments, ensuring that the business remains compliant and avoids potential penalties.

Employee Self-Service

Empowering employees with self-service access is another standout feature of Square Payroll. Through an easy-to-use employee portal, workers can access their pay stubs, tax forms, and payment history. This feature not only reduces the burden on HR personnel but also offers transparency and convenience to employees, allowing them to manage their own payroll-related information.

Direct Deposits

Square Payroll facilitates direct deposits, making the payment process seamless for both employers and employees. This feature eliminates the need for physical checks and simplifies the distribution of wages. Employees receive his or her earnings directly in his or her bank accounts, reducing delays and ensuring secure transactions.

Benefits Management

Managing employee benefits is integrated into Square Payroll’s capabilities. The software allows you to handle benefits such as health insurance and retirement plans. These benefits can be seamlessly incorporated into the payroll process, ensuring that accurate deductions are made and benefit-related data is properly managed.

Time Tracking Integration

For businesses that use Square’s time tracking tools, the integration with Square Payroll streamlines the process of calculating wages based on hours worked. This automation reduces the need for manual data entry and improves accuracy, as hours worked are directly incorporated into the payroll calculations.

Contractor Payments

Square Payroll extends its functionality to contractor payments as well. It simplifies the process of paying contractors and ensures compliance with 1099 tax reporting requirements. This feature can be particularly beneficial for businesses that work with a mix of employees and contractors.

Employee Onboarding

Bringing new employees into the payroll system is made easier with Square Payroll. The software facilitates the onboarding process by collecting tax forms and payment details from new hires. This feature helps ensure that new employees are swiftly integrated into the payroll system without administrative delays.

Payroll Reporting

Informed decision-making relies on accurate and accessible data. Square Payroll offers a range of payroll reporting options that provide insights into payroll expenses, taxes, and other critical information. These reports aid businesses in analyzing their financial data and planning effectively.

Integration with Square Ecosystem

For businesses already using other Square products, the integration capabilities of Square Payroll are a boon. The software seamlessly integrates with other Square tools, creating a unified business management ecosystem. This centralization of data and processes improves efficiency and minimizes the need for manual data transfer between systems.

Where Square Payroll Software Stands Out
Where-Square-Payroll-Software-Stands-Out

User-Friendly Interface

Square Payroll’s interface is designed with simplicity in mind. It stands out for its ease of use, making it accessible to business owners who may not have extensive experience in payroll management. The intuitive layout and clear navigation make it easy for users to handle payroll tasks without feeling overwhelmed.

Integration Capabilities

Square Payroll sets itself apart by seamlessly integrating with other Square products, creating a cohesive business management ecosystem. The integration enhances efficiency by centralizing data and streamlining various business operations. This capability is particularly advantageous for businesses already using Square tools for point of sale, invoicing, and other functions.

Cost-Effective Solution

For small to medium-sized businesses, Square Payroll offers a cost-effective payroll management solution. Its pricing structure makes it accessible to businesses with limited resources, allowing them to benefit from automated payroll processing without breaking the bank.

Time Savings

Automated payroll calculations and tax processing save businesses a substantial amount of time. With Square Payroll, manual calculations, data entry, and tax filings are minimized, allowing business owners to focus on other critical aspects of their operations.

Accuracy and Compliance

The automated tax calculations and deductions offered by Square Payroll enhance accuracy and compliance. This reduces the likelihood of errors in payroll processing and ensures that businesses remain in adherence to federal and state tax regulations.

PRO TIPS >>> Gusto vs. Roll Payroll

Where Square Payroll Software Falls Short

Limited Scalability

Square Payroll is best suited for small to medium-sized businesses. Its simplicity might become a limitation for larger enterprises with more complex payroll needs or those experiencing rapid growth.

Multi-State Payroll Complexity

Businesses operating in multiple states might find Square Payroll’s automated tax calculations insufficient to handle the complexities of varying tax laws, regulations, and reporting requirements across different jurisdictions.

Industry-Specific Needs

Certain industries, such as healthcare or construction, have unique payroll requirements. Square Payroll’s general approach might not cater to the specialized needs of these industries.

International Operations

Businesses with international operations or employees might find Square Payroll’s focus on US-based payroll insufficient to meet their global payroll needs.

How to Qualify for Square Payroll Software
How-to-Qualify-for-Square-Payroll-Software

To qualify for Square Payroll software, follow these steps to ensure that the software meets your business needs:

Assess Business Size and Type

Determine if your business falls within the small to medium-sized category, which Square Payroll is primarily designed for. Evaluate if your business’s size and structure align with the software’s target audience.

Understand Payroll Complexity

Review your payroll requirements. Square Payroll is best suited for businesses with basic payroll needs. If your payroll process involves complex calculations, multi-state operations, or specific industry requirements, assess if Square Payroll can accommodate them.

Check Geographic Suitability

Confirm that your business operates within the United States, as Square Payroll is tailored to US businesses subject to US tax regulations. If your operations are outside the US, the software might not be suitable.

Evaluate HR Needs

Consider whether your business requires comprehensive HR features beyond payroll processing. Square Payroll offers some HR functionalities, but if you need advanced HR management, you might need additional software.

Review Integration Requirements

If you’re already using other Square products or tools, assess if the integration capabilities of Square Payroll enhance your existing business management system.

Budget Consideration

Evaluate your budget and determine if Square Payroll’s pricing aligns with your financial resources. Consider if the software offers good value for its features compared to other options.

How to Apply for Square Payroll Software

Create a Square Account

If you don’t have a Square account, visit the Square website and sign up. Provide your business information and create your account.

After creating your account, log in using your Square credentials.

Access Payroll Services

From your Square dashboard, navigate to the “Payroll” or “Payroll Services” section. This is where you can explore and initiate the application process.

Review Payroll Features and Pricing

Take time to review the features included in the Square Payroll subscription, as well as the associated pricing details. Ensure they align with your business’s needs.

Start the Application Process

Click on the option to “Get Started” or “Sign Up” for Square Payroll. This will initiate the application process.

Provide Business Details

Fill in your business name, industry, location, and other relevant information as prompted. Make sure all details are accurate.

Select Payroll Preferences

Choose your preferred payroll settings, including payment frequency (e.g., weekly, biweekly, monthly), number of employees, and whether you work with contractors.

Connect Bank Account

Link your business bank account to Square Payroll. This is necessary to facilitate payroll processing and direct deposits.

Enter Employee Details

If you have employees, input their information such as names, addresses, Social Security numbers, and tax withholding details.

Verify Business Identity

Depending on your location and regulations, Square might require additional verification steps to ensure your business’s identity.

Review and Confirm Subscription

Review the subscription plan details, including pricing and any additional charges. Confirm that you agree to the terms and conditions.

Set Up Payment Method

Set up your payment method to cover the subscription fees and other costs associated with using Square Payroll.

Complete Application

Once you’ve provided all necessary information and verified your identity, submit your application.

Access Your Payroll Dashboard

Once approved, log in to your Square account and access your payroll dashboard. Here, you can start setting up payroll, inputting employee hours, and managing payments.

GET SMARTER >>>Gusto Payroll Review

Alternatives to Square Payroll Software

Gusto

If you’re looking for an easy-to-use payroll solution that also offers advanced HR features, Gusto could be a great fit. It’s known for its user-friendly interface and comprehensive HR functionalities.

ADP Workforce Now

If you need a full-fledged HR and payroll solution that scales with your business, ADP Workforce Now might be worth considering. It offers a range of features including payroll, time tracking, benefits administration, and talent management.

Customer Reviews

Square payroll has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Customer reviews highlight Square Payroll software’s strengths in user-friendliness, automated tax calculations, employee self-service, and integration capabilities. While the software is generally well-received, businesses are advised to assess their unique requirements and the software’s limitations to ensure it aligns with their payroll management needs.

Pro Tips

Scalability

Choose payroll software that can grow with your business. Ensure it can handle an increase in the number of employees and any additional complexities that might arise as your business expands.

User-Friendly Interface

Opt for software with an intuitive user interface. A user-friendly design reduces the learning curve and makes it easier for you and your team to navigate and use the software effectively.

Integration Capabilities

Consider whether the payroll software integrates with your existing tools, such as accounting software or time tracking systems. Seamless integration can save time and reduce errors from manual data entry.

Compliance

Ensure the payroll software stays up-to-date with changing tax regulations and compliance requirements. This helps you avoid errors, penalties, and potential legal issues.

Employee Self-Service

Choose software that offers an employee self-service portal. Allowing employees to access their pay stubs and tax forms independently reduces administrative work and empowers your team.

Automated Calculations

Look for software with automated tax calculations and payroll processing. This reduces the risk of errors and saves time by eliminating manual calculations.

Support and Training

Consider the level of customer support and training offered by the software provider. Having access to reliable support and training resources can help you make the most of the software’s features.

Mobile Accessibility

If you’re frequently on the move, prioritize software with mobile accessibility. This allows you to manage payroll tasks and access information from your mobile devices.

Security Measures

Payroll involves sensitive financial and personal information. Ensure the software employs strong security measures, such as encryption and secure servers, to protect your data.

Regular Updates

Select software that receives regular updates and enhancements. This ensures you’re using the latest features, staying compliant with changing regulations, and benefiting from improvements.

Data Backup and Recovery

Check if the software provides data backup and recovery options. Your payroll data is crucial, and having reliable backup measures in place safeguards against data loss.

Trial Period

Whenever possible, take advantage of free trials or demos to test the software’s functionality and compatibility with your business’s needs before committing.

Review Feedback

Read reviews and testimonials from other businesses using the software. Real-world experiences can give you insights into the software’s strengths and potential shortcomings.

Regular Audits

Periodically audit your payroll data to ensure accuracy and compliance. Payroll software is a tool, but human oversight remains crucial to avoid any unexpected issues.

Recap

When evaluating payroll software, consider scalability, integration capabilities, and compliance with tax regulations. Assess your business’s payroll requirements, growth prospects, and budget to determine the best fit.

For effective payroll management, define your needs, prioritize security, and take advantage of software features like automated calculations and mobile accessibility. Regular audits, data backup, and employee training are key aspects of maintaining accurate and compliant payroll operations. By applying these insights, you can select the right software, streamline payroll tasks, and focus on growth.

Post Comment

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Related Post

© 2025 Talent Kiwi. All Rights Reserved.

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x

© 2025 Talent Kiwi. All Rights Reserved.

Want to expand your knowledge? Check out our sister sites for expert insights!

Attract and Retain Your Best Employees.

Get talent management content curated for you and delivered daily.