Table of Contents
Our Verdict
The king is Gusto HR anytime you need a comprehensive HR management solution. It offers a robust suite of features, including payroll processing, benefits administration, time tracking, and compliance management.
However, if you focus more on project management and task organization, ClickUp is the champion here. You enjoy a flexible and customizable platform with features like task boards, Gantt charts, and integrations with various tools.
Why Choose Gusto HR
Who Gusto HR Is Best For
Choose Gusto HR if you’re someone who:
- Loves simple, intuitive software.
- Needs an all-in-one HR, payroll, and benefits solution.
- Values strong customer support.
- Wants to automate HR tasks to save time.
- Appreciates transparent, affordable pricing.
- Requires compliance assistance and resources.
- Operates a small to medium-sized business.
Who Gusto HR Isn't Best For
Consider other alternatives if you’re an individual who:
- Requires advanced, enterprise-level HR features.
- Wants highly customizable workflows.
- Needs specialized industry-specific tools.
- Expects integration with niche or less common software.
- Prefers direct, dedicated account management.
Why Choose ClickUp
Who Is ClickUp Best For
ClickUp is your best choice if you’re someone who:
- Loves highly customizable workflows.
- Needs an all-in-one project management solution.
- Values detailed task tracking and collaboration features.
- Enjoys using multiple integrations with other tools.
- Wants to manage both personal and professional projects in one platform.
- Prioritizes having a wide range of views (list, board, Gantt, etc.).
- Appreciates advanced automation and time tracking features.
- Prefers flexibility in task management and organization.
Who ClickUp Isn't Best For
You’re not likely going to find ClickUp more useful if you’re someone who:
- Prefers a very simple, minimalistic interface.
- Needs a quick setup with minimal customization.
- Wants a tool with a gentle learning curve.
- Prioritizes a more specific, specialized project management tool.
- Dislikes dealing with complex feature sets.
- Cherishes speed and simplicity over extensive functionality.
Main Differences
| Gusto HR | ClickUp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Ideal For |
|
|
||
|
Standout Features |
|
|
||
|
Pricing |
|
|
Standout Features
Gusto HR Standout Features
Gusto is a comprehensive HR platform that makes managing your workforce simpler and more efficient. Consider it for your:
Payroll processing
Gusto makes payroll a breeze. It automates the entire process, ensuring you pay your employees accurately and on time, every time. You can handle payroll for full-time, part-time, and contract workers, and Gusto even takes care of tax filings and year-end forms. This saves you a lot of time and reduces the risk of errors.
Employee benefits administration
Managing employee benefits can become complicated, but Gusto simplifies it. You can offer a range of benefits, from health insurance to retirement plans, and Gusto helps you set up and administer them. The platform integrates with various benefits providers. So it’s easy for you to provide competitive packages that attract and retain top talent.
Onboarding
Gusto streamlines the onboarding process for new hires. You can send offer letters, set up direct deposit, and manage paperwork all within the platform. This creates a smooth onboarding experience for new employees, helping them get up and running quickly without the usual hassle of paperwork.
Time tracking
The platform’s time tracking feature allows you to monitor employee hours directly within the platform. Employees can clock in and out, track breaks, and log overtime, all of which can be automatically synced with payroll. This feature ensures accurate timekeeping and simplifies payroll processing.
Compliance support
Staying compliant with labor laws and regulations is crucial, and Gusto helps you navigate this complex area. The platform provides automatic updates on changing laws, assists with tax filings, and offers compliance tools like I-9 and W-2 form management.
Employee self-service
The HR platform empowers your employees with a self-service portal where they can access their pay stubs, benefits information, and tax documents. They can also update personal information. This transparency and accessibility improve employee satisfaction.
HR tools and support
Beyond payroll and benefits, Gusto offers a suite of HR tools to help you manage your team effectively. You can track employee performance, manage PTO requests, and store important documents securely. Plus, Gusto provides HR experts who are available to offer advice and support whenever you need it.
Integrations
Gusto integrates seamlessly with other tools you might already be using, such as accounting software, time-tracking apps, and CRM systems. These integrations help you create a more cohesive and efficient workflow, minimizing the need for manual data entry and reducing the risk of errors.
PRO TIPS >>>Â BambooHR: The Best HR Software Around?
ClickUp Standout Features
ClickUp has several standout features that set it apart from other project management tools:
Customizable views
ClickUp lets you view your tasks in multiple ways—List, Board, Calendar, Gantt, and more. You can choose the view that works best for your workflow, giving you the flexibility to manage tasks the way you prefer.
Everything in one place
With ClickUp, you can manage tasks, docs, goals, chats, and even time tracking, all within one platform. This means there’s no need for multiple tools to keep track of your projects—you can do it all in one place.
Automation
Save time with ClickUp’s automation features. Create automated workflows that handle repetitive tasks like moving tasks between stages, assigning them to team members, or sending notifications. This lets you focus on what really matters.
Custom fields
Customize tasks to fit your specific needs by adding custom fields. Whether you need to track budgets, deadlines, or anything unique to your project, custom fields let you tailor ClickUp to your workflow.
Integrations
ClickUp integrates with over 1,000 tools, including Slack, Google Drive, and Trello. This makes it easy to connect all your existing tools and streamline your work processes without leaving ClickUp.
Goals and OKRs
You can set, track, and manage your goals and objectives directly in ClickUp. This feature allows you to break down big goals into smaller, actionable tasks, ensuring everyone on your team aligns and works towards the same objectives.
Time tracking
ClickUp’s built-in time tracking allows you to monitor how much time is spent on each task. This is ideal for managing billable hours, understanding where your team’s time goes, and optimizing productivity.
Collaboration tools
From comments and mentions to assigned comments and real-time editing in documents, ClickUp facilitates seamless team collaboration. You can keep all communication tied to the tasks they relate to, avoiding the chaos of scattered messages.
Templates
ClickUp offers a variety of templates for tasks, projects, and even entire workflows. Whether you’re managing a marketing campaign, software development, or personal tasks, you can get started quickly with a template that fits your needs.
Advanced reporting
Generate detailed reports on task completion, time tracking, and team performance with ClickUp’s advanced reporting features. This gives you actionable insights to improve your workflows and drive better results.
Pros and Cons of Gusto HR
Pros
- Simplifies payroll processing.
- Offers comprehensive benefits management.
- Integrates with various accounting tools.
- Provides employee self-service portal.
- Automates tax filings.
- Delivers easy-to-use interface.
- Supports compliance with labor laws.
- Customizes reports and workflows.
Cons
- Limits features in lower-tier plans.
- Charges extra for certain services.
- Lacks advanced HR functionalities for large businesses.
- Restricts international payroll capabilities.
- Experiences occasional customer support delays.
- Requires setup time for new users.
Pros and Cons of ClickUp
Pros
- Customizes workflows and views extensively.
- Integrates with a wide range of third-party tools.
- Automates repetitive tasks with ease.
- Manages everything in one platform, from tasks to documents.
- Tracks time directly within the app.
- Collaborates effectively with real-time comments and editing.
- Sets and monitors goals and OKRs.
- Accesses a variety of templates for quick setup.
Cons
- Experiences a learning curve due to its many features.
- Encounters occasional performance issues with large projects.
- Deals with some features that may be too complex for small teams.
- Finds that the mobile app lacks some functionality.
- Requires more time to fully customize for specific needs.
Customer Reviews
Gusto doesn’t have a good standing when it comes to customer reviews. It has a poor rating of 2.4 out of 5-star based on 2,072 customer feedbacks on TrustPilot. ClickUp has an average rating of 2.8 stars out of 5 based on 287 customer reviews on TrustPilot. You can’t really say that one is better than the other in terms of review.
GET SMARTER >>>Â Paychex Flex HR Software: Get It or Not?
Competitors
BambooHR
BambooHR is a cloud-based human resources (HR) management software that streamline and simplify your HR processes. With BambooHR, you can effectively manage various HR tasks, including employee onboarding, offboarding, time off requests, performance reviews, and benefits administration.
The software offers a user-friendly interface, making it easy for you to navigate and access essential information. Additionally, BambooHR provides customizable features to accommodate the unique needs of your business, ensuring that your HR processes align with your specific requirements.
Rippling
Rippling is a versatile HR and payroll platform. It offers a comprehensive suite of features, including global payroll, benefits administration, time tracking, expense management, IT management, and employee onboarding/offboarding.
By centralizing these functions, Rippling helps you save time, reduce administrative burdens, and improve compliance.
Whether you’re a small business or a large corporation, Rippling can simplify your HR processes, enhance your overall efficiency, and provide a centralized hub for managing your workforce.
Pro Tips
- Define your core needs: Gusto is a comprehensive HR and payroll management tool, ideal for handling employee benefits, payroll, and compliance. ClickUp, on the other hand, is a project management and productivity tool that’s best for task management, collaboration, and workflow automation. Determine whether your priority is HR management or project management.
- Evaluate usability and training needs: ClickUp is famous for its customization options and can be complex to set up initially, which can require training. Gusto is more straightforward, with a focus on user-friendly HR management. Consider your team’s tech-savviness and the time you can dedicate to onboarding.
- Review pricing models: Both tools offer different pricing structures. Gusto has a tiered pricing model based on the services you need, while ClickUp offers a more flexible pricing plan based on team size and feature requirements. Compare the costs in the context of your budget and the features you need.
- Consider integration capabilities: Evaluate how each tool integrates with your existing software. Gusto integrates well with accounting software like QuickBooks, while ClickUp offers integration with a wide range of productivity tools like Slack, Google Workspace, and more. Choose based on which integrations enhance your workflow.
- Assess team size and growth plans: If you’re managing a small to mid-sized business and need to streamline HR tasks, Gusto is a great fit. For teams that are more project-focused, particularly in creative or tech industries, ClickUp offers flexibility in managing projects as your team grows.
Recap
Gusto is perfect if you’re looking for a solution to streamline payroll, manage employee benefits, and handle HR compliance. Adopt it if you prioritize HR tasks. ClickUp, on the other hand, shines as a project management tool, offering robust features for task management, team collaboration, and workflow automation, which is ideal if your focus is on enhancing productivity and project efficiency.
Consider your integration needs, team size, usability preferences, and budget to determine which tool best aligns with your goals.
